top of page

Montana taxpayers deserve more details about local government spending

2 minutes ago
4 min read

Magnifying glass over local government spending report showing budget categories and $53,000,000 total on a desk.

Montana’s communities are growing, and local governments are spending more to keep up. Roads need maintenance, public safety departments need resources, and expanding communities require investments in infrastructure and public services. Those are legitimate responsibilities of local government. But as spending continues to climb, taxpayers deserve to know whether the cost of local government is growing at a reasonable pace.


A review of financial reports from Bozeman, Billings, and Missoula shows that local government expenses have increased substantially since 2018. The size of those increases is particularly striking when compared with population growth and inflation.


Between fiscal years 2018 and 2024, Bozeman’s governmental activities expenses increased from approximately $47.4 million to $87.5 million, a nearly 85% increase. Missoula’s expenses grew from $48.1 million to $114.3 million, an increase of approximately 138%. Billings experienced a smaller, though still significant, increase, with expenses rising from $119.6 million to $158.3 million, or about 32%.


Population growth accounts for some of this change, but not all of it. Bozeman’s population grew approximately 24% over the same period, while its governmental expenses increased by nearly 85%. Missoula’s population grew by roughly 4%, compared with a 138% increase in expenses. Billings’ population increased approximately 11%, while its expenses grew by 32%.


Per-capita spending tells an even more revealing story. In 2018, Bozeman spent approximately $1,017 per resident on governmental activities. By 2024, that figure had reached $1,511, a nominal increase of 48.5%. Missoula’s per-capita spending more than doubled, rising from approximately $641 to $1,462. Billings’ increased from roughly $1,093 to $1,303, or 19%.


Of course, inflation matters. The cost of labor, construction, equipment, and other public services has increased over the past several years. But even after adjusting for inflation, Bozeman’s per-capita expenses increased approximately 19%, while Missoula’s rose by roughly 83%. Billings’ inflation-adjusted per-capita expenses, by contrast, declined by approximately 5%.


Billings provides an important contrast. Although its total governmental expenses increased by nearly one-third, spending per resident grew more slowly than inflation. In other words, the city spent more in nominal dollars, but the increase did not keep pace with the combined effects of inflation and population growth. This demonstrates why looking at total budget increases alone can be misleading. Taxpayers need to understand both how much their government spends and how those expenditures change relative to the cost of providing services and the size of the community.


So what is driving the growth in local government spending, and are taxpayers getting a commensurate return?


The issue is especially relevant when considering property taxes. Property taxes are an important source of local government revenue, and the amount local governments seek to collect is closely tied to their adopted budgets. Once a budget is established, local governments determine the mill levies needed to fund it, subject to state law and applicable revenue limits. As a result, decisions about government spending have a direct effect on the property-tax burden carried by residents.


Between 2018 and 2024, Bozeman’s property-tax revenue grew from approximately $22.5 million to $45.5 million, an increase of 102 percent. Billings’ increased from $38.7 million to $67.5 million, or nearly 75%. Missoula’s rose from $31.8 million to $42.7 million, an increase of approximately 34%.


Measured per resident, property-tax revenue increased in all three cities. Bozeman went from approximately $484 per person in 2018 to $785 in 2024. Billings increased from $353 to $556, while Missoula rose from $424 to $546. Even after accounting for inflation, property-tax revenue per resident increased in each city.


Individual tax bills are affected by taxable property values, mill levies, changes in the tax base, and state tax policy. However, the growth in property-tax collections demonstrates why local budget decisions deserve greater scrutiny. When governments approve larger budgets and seek additional property-tax revenue to support them, taxpayers should understand what is driving those increases and how the money will be used.


This is not particularly an argument against funding essential public services or making responsible investments in growing communities. Local officials have real obligations, and population growth can bring significant infrastructure and service demands. However, when local government expenses rise substantially faster than population and inflation, taxpayers have every reason to ask why.


Montana residents should be able to easily determine how much their local government spends, how quickly that spending is growing, and how those increases compare with the growth of the community. Yet this information is often buried in lengthy annual financial reports and scattered across budget documents, making meaningful comparisons difficult for the average taxpayer.


Local governments should make that information more accessible by publishing an annual spending report that tracks total expenditures and per-capita spending over time, adjusts for inflation, and compares spending growth with population growth. The report should also include property-tax revenue and revenue per resident, while distinguishing recurring operating costs from one-time capital projects, debt payments, and enterprise activities. 


One reform that could help bring this much-needed spending and property tax transparency is Truth in Taxation. Under this policy, local governments are required to advertise the impact of a proposed budget on property tax collections and hold a public hearing before acting. 


Transparency is a basic responsibility of the government, particularly when taxpayers are being asked to contribute more. Local officials should be prepared to explain not only how much they are spending, but why those costs are increasing and what residents are receiving in return. They deserve clear numbers, meaningful comparisons, and accountability.


c526bb6b-edc8-4450-a9b0-d78e53e8978e_edited.jpg
MTN-States-Policy-Logo-2023_Logomark-White.png

info@mountainstatespolicy.org

208-295-9525

PO Box 2639    Coeur d'Alene, ID      83816

Terms of Service & Privacy Policy

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • TikTok
bottom of page