top of page

Reality check: When the full Idaho ed choice report contradicts the narrative

18 hours ago
4 min read

Headlines can be factually correct and still leave readers uninformed.


The coverage of Idaho's first report on the new Parental Choice Tax Credit offers a useful example. Scan the web or read the newspapers and you'd think it was armageddon. One anti-choice legislator claimed the data was "catastrophic."


The bluster is impressive. And it is wrong.


This weekend, we scanned news station websites, media social media accounts and newspapers. We found only one headline about the report that was neutral. We found none that actually highlighted a positive aspect of the report.


Cartoon reporter feeds Idaho School Choice Report into a headline filter, spitting out Wealthy Families! Christian Schools!

Instead, headlines complained of "wealthy families" or "Christian schools." To some, those findings might warrant examination.


But so do more than 12,000 student awards, more than 3,000 parents qualifying for income priority, assistance for 600 students with declared disabilities, use in every legislative district in the state, and nearly $11.6 million distributed in advance payments.


The negative findings received headline treatment. The positive findings required digging - something most citizens don't have time to do.


A serious evaluation should explain what the data establishes, what remains unknown and which conclusions outrun the evidence.


An average doing more work than it can support


Let's start by talking about the widely reported $178,000 average adjusted gross income of a participating family. Is that number directly from the report? Yes. Does it need context? Absolutely.


The report provides a mean but no overall median or detailed income distribution, so it does not establish what the typical participating household actually earned.


The Idaho Capital Sun compounded the problem by comparing the program’s mean adjusted gross income with Idaho’s median household income. Those are different statistics measuring income differently. Readers were offered a dramatic comparison without the statistical consistency needed to support its implication.


Here's something you likely didn't see in the newspapers or media reports: among parents who qualified for income priority using their 2024 income and subsequently filed 2025 returns, the average adjusted gross income was just $66,000, with an average household size of five.


Those households may be inconvenient to a sweeping narrative about wealthy beneficiaries, but they are also in the report.


Here's something else you likely didn't see: 370 families who qualified for the income-priority credits in 2024, exceeded the income threshold in 2025.


Did they suddenly get rich? No. After all, the applicable 2024 priority threshold was $93,600 for four people and $109,740 for five. A hypothetical five-person household earning $110,000 would exceed it by just $260.


The report places those households slightly above the threshold in the same broad category as substantially higher earners.


The other thing to keep in mind is this: if money had been exhausted by families under the income threshold, those above it would not have qualified in the first place.


A geographic lesson


Headlines screamed of the fact that a majority of the awards went to those in Ada and Canyon counties. This is not unexepcted, however. After all, those two counties alone account for almost 41% of the entire state population.


What if I told you there was participation in every legislative district in the state? What if I told you that, when you adjust for population, Idaho, Latah and Kootenai counties actually showed the largest participation rates? Both of these things are true, but you can't find that data in many news stories.


The data is even more surprising given that opponents claimed there were no choice options available in rural areas.


What about prior public school enrollment?


Collage of Idaho news headlines showing reports that education tax credits mostly went to higher-income families and private schools.

The report shows roughly 25% of students previously attended a public school. This has been portrayed as "alarming," with opponents claiming the program is only helping "rich kids" who were already in private school.


The analysis, however, does not support the conclusion that those families needed no financial assistance.


Enrollment history reveals little about the sacrifices required to maintain an educational arrangement. It does not identify borrowing, additional work, support from relatives or reductions in other household spending. The report did not measure those circumstances.


Nor does never attending an Idaho public school establish that a child was already attending private school before the program began. That category can include homeschoolers, children beginning school and students previously educated outside Idaho.


The inference that prior enrollment demonstrates comfortable affordability requires evidence the report does not supply.


Funding "religious schools"


The words "Christian schools" were featured prominently in several newspaper headlines. Some opponents and reporters went so far as to say the religious schools were being "funded by taxpayers."


First, the state of Idaho is not funding any of these private schools. Not one dollar in the program was sent to a school. The tax refunds were sent to families. It would be the equivalent of saying Idaho was funding Albertsons because a family took a grocery tax credit.


And whether a school is religious or not tells us nothing about whether it meets a student’s needs, whether parents are satisfied or whether assistance makes continued enrollment financially sustainable.


It's also worth noting that the Idaho LAUNCH program does virtually the same thing, only at the college level.


Six hundred students deserve accurate arithmetic


The report identifies 600 students with declared disabilities awarded approximately $3.5 million.


The Capital Sun described those students as less than 1% of participants. The correct figure is approximately 4.9%—about one in twenty.


That is a straightforward mathematical error with a consequential effect: It substantially understates these students’ share of participation.


An analysis concerned with whom the program serves should give those students accurate accounting and meaningful attention.


Advanced payments belong in the access discussion


Perhaps the most under appreciated part of the report is the fact that nearly 2,500 students received almost $12 million in advanced payments.


Timing is central to affordability, and this mechanism of the Idaho Parental Choice Tax Credit allowed parents who perhaps couldn't afford to take a chance some financial breathing room.


Like any program, Idaho’s Parental Choice Tax Credit deserves rigorous scrutiny. So does the coverage of it.


A report documenting assistance for more than 12,000 students—including 600 with declared disabilities—and awards to more than 3,000 income-priority parents shouldn't be reduced to a campaign slogan about "wealthy families" and "Christian schools."


Critics couldn't stop the program in the legislature. They couldn't get it thrown out in the courts. Now they are litigating it again.


The findings of the state tax commission do not settle every question about the program’s effectiveness, but they belong prominently in any honest assessment.

c526bb6b-edc8-4450-a9b0-d78e53e8978e_edited.jpg
MTN-States-Policy-Logo-2023_Logomark-White.png

info@mountainstatespolicy.org

208-295-9525

PO Box 2639    Coeur d'Alene, ID      83816

Terms of Service & Privacy Policy

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • X
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • TikTok
bottom of page